Dr. Howard A. Kelly’s The Stereo Clinic: health science pedagogy and the egalitarian future of 3D clinical visualization
Keywords:health sciences education, pedagogy, 3D, history of medicine, stereoscope, stereoscopic imagery
This article situates emerging three-dimensional (3D) visualization technologies in the health sciences within the broader historical context of the stereoscope. Although 3D visualization technologies enhance pedagogy and deepen student engagement, they are generally cost-prohibitive and therefore inaccessible for many institutions. In light of this issue, the authors consider the work of American gynecologist and founding member of The Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore, Maryland, Dr. Howard Atwood Kelly (1858–1943). A monumental work, Kelly’s The Stereo Clinic is a multivolume publication whose focal point was the stereoscope, an image-viewing device that can be seen as a prototype for present-day 3D technologies. Each installment presents a step-by-step overview of a specific surgical procedure using a didactic narrative and corresponding stereoscopic images that illustrate the clinical practices. Significantly, Kelly understood The Stereo Clinic as an egalitarian project that provided high-quality educational resources to students and practicing physicians who did not have access to world-class clinical suites and teaching institutions. Furthermore, he viewed The Stereo Clinic as a remedy to the commonplace frustrations of medical education, such as crowded surgical suites, and the hazards of in-person observation. The Stereo Clinic is an important case study because it reveals a medical profession at the turn of the twentieth century preoccupied with 3D visualization. Inventive clinicians such as Kelly did not only advocate for this technology on the strength of its pedagogical value; they also articulated the equalitarian nature of this medium and produced 3D technology accessible to a wide audience.
Jacquesson T, Simon E, Dauleac C, Margueron L, Robinson P, Mertens P. Stereoscopic three-dimensional visualization: interest for neuroanatomy teaching in medical school. Surg Radiol Anat. 2020;42(6):719-27.
Meyer ER, Cui D. Anatomy visualizations using stereopsis: assessment and implication of stereoscopic virtual models in anatomical education. Adv Exp Med Biol. 2020;1235:117–30.
Weiss NM, Schneider A, Hempel JM, Uecker FC, van Bonn SM, Schraven SP, et al. Evaluating the didactic value of 3D visualization in otosurgery. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2021;278(4):1027–33.
Chhaya N, Helmy O, Piri N, Palacio A, Schaal S. Comparison of 2D and 3D Video displays for teaching vitreoretinal surgery. Retina. 2018;38(8):1556–61.
Pottle J. Virtual reality and the transformation of medical education. Future Healthc J. 2019;6(3):181–5.
Lessick S, Kraft M. Facing reality: the growth of virtual reality and health sciences libraries. J Med Libr Assoc. 2017;105(4):407–17.
Motsinger SK. Complete anatomy. J Med Libr Assoc. 2020;108(1):155–7.
Ogdon DC. Hololens and Vive Pro: virtual reality headsets. J Med Libr Assoc. 2019;107(1):118–21.
Kelly HA. Examination of bladder and catheterization of ureters/dilatation and curettage. Troy, NY: Southworth Company; 1908.
Bissell DK, Howard A. Suspension of kidney. Kelly HAL, Robert M, eds. Troy, NY: Southworth Company; 1915.
Bodine JA. Dr. Bodine’s operation for hernia under cocaine, pt 1/Dr. Bodine’s operation for hernia under cocaine, pt 2. Kelly HA, ed. Troy, NY: Southworth Company; 1909.
Crile GW. Excision of carcinoma of the neck/excision of tuberculous gland of neck. Kelly HA, ed. Troy, NY: Southworth Company; 1911.
Dunham K. Stereoroentgenograhy pulmonary tuberculosis pt 1/Stereoroentgenograhy pulmonary tuberculosis pt 2. Kelly HAL, Robert M, eds. Troy, NY: Southworth Company; 1915.
Judd EFAB, Arthur D. Appendectomy, amputation of breast/exopthalmic goiter, removal of sarcoma. Kelly HA, editor. Troy, NY: Southworth Company; 1911.
Kelly HA. Suspension of the uterus/examination and recording abdominal tumors. Kelly HA, ed. Troy, NY: Southworth Company; 1909.
Kelly HA. Abdomnial hysterectomy/abdominal pan-hysteromyomectomy. Kelly HA, ed. Troy, NY: Southworth Company; 1909.
Kelly HA. Relaxed vaginal outlet, pt 1/Relaxed vaginal outlet, pt 2. Kelly HA, ed. Troy, NY: Southworth Company; 1909.
Mayo C. Enucleation of cystic adenoma of thyroid/thyroidectomy, ligation of thyroid artery. Kelly HA, ed. Troy, NY: Southworth Company; 1910.
Mayo WJ. Gastrojenunostomy/cholecystotomy with removal of gall stone. Kelly HA, editor. Troy, NY: Southworth Company; 1910.
Murphy J. Pott’s fracture, removal of postsacral teratoma/hysterectomy, arthroplasty for anklosed knee. Kelly HA, ed. Troy, NY: Southworth Company; 1910.
Darrah WC. Stereo views: a history of stereographs in america and their collection. Gettysburg, PA: Times and News Publishing; 1964.
The stereoscope, the vitascope and the phonograph in medical teaching. The American Journal of Surgery. 1906;20(5):149.
Davidson JM. Remarks on the value of stereoscopic photography and skiagraphy: records of clinical and pathological appearances. The British Medical Journal. 1898;2(1979):1669–71.
Cunningham DJ. Imperial stereoscopic anatomy of the head and neck. New York: Imperial Pub; 1911.
Waterston D. Edinburgh stereoscopic atlas of anatomy. London: Caxton Pub; 1905.
Rainforth SI. The stereoscopic skin clinic. New York: Medical Art Pub.; 1911.
Davis AW. Dr. Kelly of Hopkins: surgeon, scientist, Christian. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Press; 1959.
Hunner G. In Memoriam – Howard Atwood Kelly. Transactions of the American Gynecological Society. 1943;68:295–305.
The Stereoclinic. New York Medical Journal. 1911;93(6):346–7.
The Stereo-Clinic. The Journal of the American Medical Association. 1910;54(5):406.
The Stereo-Clinic. The American Journal of Surgery. 1910;23(4):122–3.
The Stereoclinic. Journal of Osteopathy. 1911;17(4):313–4.
Kelly’s “The Stereo-Clinic.” The American Journal of Clinical Medicine. 1910;17(10 ):1146.
“The Stereo-Clinic.” The Journal of the Indiana State Medical Association. 1910;3(7):299.
Wealth of material. Boston Evening Transcript. 14 Nov 1912.
Boston surgery is good. Boston Evening Transcript. 27 Oct 1915.
Copyright (c) 2022 Sebastian C. Galbo, Keith C. Mages
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.